Branch Secretary : suz.muna.unite@gmail.com
  

Cancer all-clear for night work based on ‘bad science’

Methodological flaws "invalidate" conclusions

 

Night shifts are bad for your health, and many of our members who work night shifts have been particularly concerned at the mounting evidence that night work is linked to breast cancer risk.  In October an Oxford University study found that the classification of night work as a cause of breast cancer ‘is no longer justified.  This sounded like good news, but three of the most respected researchers on night work and breast cancer have now said they “fully disagree” with this conclusion, noting a succession of methodological flaws in the research “invalidate” its conclusions.

 

 

Harvard Medical School epidemiologist Eva Schernhammer told Hazards magazine that given the Oxford study’s “bad science” it was “not surprising” it found no effect. She said its many shortcomings “preclude it from making the conclusion that there is no association between night work and breast cancer risk.”

 

Johnni Hansen, a researcher with the Danish Cancer Society, added: “They base their conclusion on a poor study, but even worse is that their conclusion may hinder preventive initiatives for night workers.” Richard Stevens, of the University of Connecticut medical school, who has written influential papers on the topic with both Schernhammer and Hansen, was blunt. “Why was the paper written in the first place?” he asked. The main study groups in the Oxford study were “worryingly old”, with many over retirement age, and the follow up was “unusually short”, Hansen said. The risk of women developing breast cancer appears to wane in the years after night working ends, so studying retired workers without recent exposures misses the point and the cancers, said Schernhammer, adding the higher risk is seen in women with long exposures – at least 15 years – early in their careers. Night work was sometimes defined so loosely in the study participants, a single night shift might have seen a worker added to the ‘exposed’ group despite facing minimal exposure and risk.

 

Read more about the risks in Hazards magazine.  Unite reps and health and safety reps play an important role ensuring good practice in shift work.

POST A COMMENT!

Before Posting

We welcome debate and discussion on our website, but we also want an open, respectful, inclusive space in which forms of abuse or personal attack will not be tolerated. Comments will be moderated and will be removed if they are found to be unduly offensive. You should also be very careful in posting information about your employer. Employers do visit the website and if you think a comment could get you into trouble for releasing confidential or sensitive information, or for bringing the employer into disrepute, please do not post it. It remains your individual responsibility to ensure that what you post is appropriate. Please therefore just give a moment's thought to what you are saying. The types of comments that are likely to be moderated are:


  • Personal abuse or attacks on an individual.
  • Information which breaches another person's right to confidentiality.
  • The use of offensive language, including swear words, or language which is racist, sexist, or otherwise breaches equalities standards.
  • Anything that might place the Branch or the wider union in legal jeopardy.
  • Adverts or information which is posted for commercial gain.

* Name
* Email (will not be published)
Website
Comment
* field is required

NEWS ARCHIVE